.png)
When it comes to mystery shopping, many consumers—and businesses—imagine the same thing: a random person getting the chance to critique a store they already shop at to get free stuff. However, this is just one of the many misconceptions about a practice that can be a valuable tool for businesses everywhere.
In this blog, we’ll dig into the strategy behind mystery shopping and debunk the top 10 myths people believe about it. Are you ready to do a little retail discovery? Let’s jump right in!
Although the image described above is a bad stereotype, there’s some truth to it. Mystery shopping is intended to be a scientific strategy for evaluating a business’s customer experience (CX) with various touchpoints, locations, and scenarios. By hiring an evaluator who employees aren’t familiar with, a company can simulate a realistic situation and see how staff react under what they believe are normal circumstances. To put it simply, when employees don’t know they’re being observed, the results are likely to be more accurate.
But it’s not all retail shopping and cashing in on reimbursements. To demonstrate further, here are a few examples of specific scenarios that secret shoppers might test:
This is just a small list of potential testing formats. However, it’s easy to see why a mystery shopper’s perspective would be beneficial. Businesses can gather and analyze data, ask customers to leave reviews, and follow up with service calls… but owners and executives can’t be everywhere at once. A mystery shop allows them to check various aspects of their CX, get the perspective of an expert, and generate strategies for issue resolution and overall improvement. That’s why it’s such a long-standing strategy used by businesses around the world.
Of course, just because it’s a popular protocol for evaluating CX, mystery shopping has had its fair share of bad press. Many consumers and business executives get it all wrong, and that can lead to less than optimal results. If you’re looking to bust any myths you have about the practice, you’re in the right place. Let’s take a look at the top 10 misconceptions we’ve found—and discover the truth behind them..
One of the biggest misconceptions about mystery shoppers is that anyone off the street who wants to earn a quick buck can do it. All they have to do is browse the store, complain about a few things they think could be better, and cash in. In a culture that values the hustle and ever-present “side gigs,” this is an easy myth to fall into.
In reality, professional mystery shoppers are highly-skilled individuals with experience in evaluating customer service. They’re detail-oriented and good with communication. They follow specific guidelines and objectives provided by their clients. When they’re done with a shop, they carefully generate detailed reports and provide objective, accurate, and actionable feedback. While many people are well-suited for this kind of work, real mystery shoppers must be driven, perceptive, and meticulous—not just critical consumers—in order to produce valuable results.
Similarly, mystery shopping itself can seem like a scam for those looking to start a career in this line of work. Because of fraudulent job postings, underhanded businesses, and “too good to be true” offers, there are a lot of bad vibes out there. Nobody wants to be swindled when they’re just trying to make an honest living.
While scams do exist, legitimate CX evaluation companies never ask shoppers to do anything unreasonable. For example, they would never ask shoppers to pay upfront fees or wire money to them. Neither will they unfairly reimburse them for no reason. Trusted companies like CustomerOptix and IntelliShop work with reputable business standards and provide fair compensation for completed evaluations.
Another major misconception people have is that mystery shopping is designed only to “catch employees doing something wrong.” In reality, the goal is to gather objective insights about the overall customer experience—and that includes the behavior of staff members. If employees offer high service quality, keep a clean shop, and adhere to company policies, mystery shoppers will commend them for their work.
Alternatively, if there are problems on the floor—like long-time wait staff not knowing whether a popular menu item is gluten-free—then mystery shoppers can identify these details and recommend changes to staff training. It’s all about improvement, not punishment.
One thing that many businesses get wrong about mystery shopping is that it’s only for traditional brick-and-mortar retail stores. However, this practice is used across virtually every industry—including banks, hotels, self-storage facilities, automotive services, and even government offices. Furthermore, as demonstrated, it can be used to evaluate a wide variety of touchpoints and scenarios.
Any possible customer interaction is an opportunity for analysis and improvement, and thus can be evaluated with a mystery shop.
Even if you’re open to the idea of mystery shopping, another popular myth is that feedback from these evaluations is based purely on personal opinions. This stems from a lot of the other myths we’ve seen already—that mystery shoppers are just ordinary consumers with big opinions.
But that’s just plain false. Most reputable programs use structured evaluation forms with standardized questions to ensure integrity. They combine qualitative and quantitative data to give an authentic picture of a business’s CX as possible. Plus, because professional mystery shoppers are experts at CX, they do their best to provide objective, improvement-oriented information. All these factors combine to ensure that the data collected is consistent, measurable, and actionable.
Customer surveys are a valuable method for gathering feedback about a business’s CX. However, they often reflect a customer’s memory or feelings immediately after the shopping experience, and they aren’t terribly reliable in terms of hard data.
That’s because they’re filled out by laypeople—customers who just wanted a good experience. Mystery shopping, on the other hand, offers real-time, objective observations of the full experience. Evaluators take a careful look from initial interaction to checkout and conclusion, capturing operational details that survey-takers might miss.
In reality, it’s good to use both methods and combine the data from mystery shoppers and customer surveys.
While it’s clear that mystery shopping can provide a wealth of information, many businesses may wonder whether it’s worth the investment. After all, hiring a team of evaluators to check every location, touchpoint, and scenario can add up—and small businesses must be especially careful with their budgets.
Thankfully, you don’t have to go all in on your CX evaluation program at once. Plus, CustomerOptix’s CX On Demand program is affordable, flexible, and scalable. You can schedule a mystery shop from a skilled evaluator in as little as 10 minutes. Then, if you like what you get, you can schedule recurring shops at regular intervals to check on progress, identify issues as they arise, and monitor the effectiveness of new initiatives.
Put simply, a mystery shop doesn’t have to break the bank. And it provides real, actionable insight that can boost your bottom line, both immediately and over time.
Another important factor to this strategy is that it’s not just about finding something negative. By design, mystery shopping has the capacity to uncover problems. More importantly, it can identify small issues and work towards solutions—before they get out of control or cost your business a lot of cash.
As shown, a mystery shopper can also point out positives about the way you run your business. In fact, they can show you where your company stands out from the competition, as well as what great things customers are saying about your offerings and employees. This allows you to capitalize on your successes and even motivate staff.
While less common, this myth is a potentially devastating one. Some businesses believe that mystery shopping alone can solve training issues. That’s because these executives likely also think that this strategy is all about finding out which employees are slipping up, or punishing those who step out of line.
In reality, mystery shoppers should support employees, not cause anxiety. With a CX evaluation program, businesses can steadily improve their training protocols and empower their employees to perform better at work. This boosts motivation in a positive way and optimizes the customer experience.
This is the ultimate mystery shopping myth—and it’s not remotely true! Whether you’re looking to start your career as a shopper or putting together your own CX evaluation strategy, it’s important to do your research about who you might work with. Weigh perks, costs, and reviews. Compare companies side by side when you can.
Or get the best experience right away by choosing CustomerOptix. Our nationwide network of skilled evaluators can be deployed at a moment’s notice to dig into your CX and provide actionable, data-driven insights. It’s designed with small and growing businesses in mind, so you can get access to high-end resources on your schedule—and your budget. Learn how it works and sign up now. Or check out our shopper portal to become part of our awesome team.
As we’ve seen, mystery shopping is far more than just a secret mission to critique stores. It’s a strategic, data-driven approach to improving customer experiences across industries and touchpoints. Despite what these common myths say, it’s not about catching employees off guard or collecting subjective opinions from ordinary consumers. It’s about gaining valuable insights that help businesses grow, succeed, and thrive in a competitive marketplace.
Whether you’re evaluating customer service, compliance, or operational efficiency, a well-executed mystery shopping program can uncover both strengths and areas for improvement.
How will you reshape your perception about this powerful strategy?
.svg){kind=icon}
