Unlocking Success: Hiring a Secret Shopper for Your Small Business

In today's competitive landscape, understanding and improving the customer experience (CX) is paramount. For small businesses seeking to thrive and differentiate themselves from the competition,  hiring a secret shopper is an important task. Secret shopping, also known as mystery shopping or CX evaluation, offers a unique opportunity to gain valuable insights into the customer journey and identify areas for improvement. 

Whether you're a small boutique or a local chain restaurant, the principles of effective secret shopping apply universally. Join us as we explore the key steps and considerations for hiring a secret shopper to evaluate your business. Ultimately, this will help you elevate your CX and drive sustained success.

‍

Why Do I Need to Hire a Secret Shopper?

CX evaluations, conducted by a secret shopper, offer numerous benefits for businesses looking to enhance their service and grow their customer base. By systematically assessing every touchpoint a customer has with your business, these evaluations provide invaluable insights into areas where your service excels—and where it needs improvement. Ultimately, regular CX evaluations help build a strong, customer-centric culture, leading to increased customer loyalty, positive word-of-mouth, and sustained business growth.

So what are the biggest overall benefits of hiring a secret shopper? 

‍

Get an Honest Look at the State of Your CX

Of all the techniques available for assessing customer satisfaction levels, a CX evaluation is the most objective. Gathering customer feedback from more passive sources can be beneficial… but you’re typically only dealing with either highly satisfied or dissatisfied customers. Both present extremely biased opinions. For example, if you’re looking at online reviews for your business, you’ll likely find strong, positive testimonials or the vitriolic rantings of trolls on a tirade—with little in between. 

By hiring a professional secret shopper, you’ll get an experienced reviewer who will provide honest, comprehensive feedback. Additionally, they understand the ins and outs of running a business, so they’ll be able to provide information you can actually use to strategize improvements. Scrolling through comments won’t give you that. A CX evaluation is the most essential tool in a small business’s toolbox. 

‍

Invest in Your CX with a Secret Shopper

Although it may seem like an expense, especially for small businesses, hiring a secret shopper is a solid investment. By taking the time to get a quality CX evaluation, you’ll be better able to make improvements to your business overall. You’ll know where to spend your time and efforts on upgrades. Then, your customers will see steady boosts at every touchpoint. 

After all, without a great customer experience, none of your marketing efforts will make any real impact. On the other hand, a CX evaluation strategy followed by smart adjustments in policy will almost always increase your bottom line. 

‍

Common Misconceptions about Secret Shopping

Although the concept of secret shopping is pretty common, there are many misconceptions about CX evaluations in general. If you’re a small business looking to start analyzing your CX with some outside help, you might have some misguided ideas about the process. 

Here are a few common misconceptions you might see: 

1. Only for Large Businesses: On the contrary, many small businesses see huge benefits from secret shopper evaluations. In fact, because they’re smaller in scale, CX evaluations for small businesses can have an even greater impact on customer satisfaction than bigger businesses that are already established. 
2. Too Expensive: While smaller businesses typically have smaller budgets to work with—and more at stake—a CX evaluation doesn’t have to break the bank. In fact, it can be pretty competitively priced. Of course, there is some investment involved. But if you hire a quality CX evaluation agency, you can manage your resources efficiently while still reaping the benefits. 
3. Disruptive to Operations: You might think you can spot a secret shopper from a mile away… but that’s only if the person you hired isn’t doing their job well. Professional CX evaluators conduct their evaluations discreetly, ensuring minimal disruption to maintain the authenticity of the customer experience. 
4. For Retail Businesses: Many assume secret shopping is only relevant for retail stores. However, CX evaluations can be tailored to various industries, including restaurants, service providers, and even online businesses. Any business that interacts with customers can benefit. 
5. Employee Distrust: Everyone experiences test anxiety—but a CX evaluation doesn’t have to feel like a pop quiz. When communicated effectively, using a secret shopper can become a tool for professional development, as well as an opportunity for growth… rather than a punitive measure. 

‍

Every Business Can Benefit from a Secret Shopper

The biggest misconception about secret shopping? It’s that successful businesses don’t need CX evaluations. Frankly, this is entirely untrue. If you want to keep succeeding, regular check-ins are important—regardless of your current performance. Your secret shopper may uncover rare or hidden issues that should be addressed. Ultimately, continuous improvement is the key to maintaining a competitive edge. 

Of course, this myth goes hand-in-hand with the idea that you only need one CX evaluation. Unfortunately, one secret shopper isn’t enough to uncover or solve all customer service issues. Continuous evaluations are necessary to monitor progress, adapt to changing customer expectations, and ensure consistent service quality over time. 

‍

Qualities to Look for in a Secret Shopper

Once you’re committed to the investment of a CX evaluation, you’ll want to hire a secret shopper who can give you quality feedback. Here are a few key elements to look for in a potential CX evaluator: 

• Attention to detail and observational skills. Candidates who take the time to make note of every aspect of their experience can provide better feedback than those who don’t. 
• Effective communication abilities, both written and verbal. In the end, a secret shopper is just a specific type of quality control agent. They should be able to communicate their feedback clearly and comprehensively. 
• Objectivity and impartiality. Less-than-professional candidates might try to work as secret shoppers just to get an inside scoop on their favorite stores. On the other hand, quality secret shoppers prioritize integrity over any potential perks. 
• Reliability, professionalism, and adherence to deadlines. Like with any employee, an ideal candidate will exhibit high-quality behavior in the workplace—including getting reports back to you in a reasonable time. 
• Technology proficiency (if applicable). Especially if you have any digital touchpoints, a candidate with adequate technological savvy is a bonus. 

Alternatively, you can hire an experienced CX evaluation agency to take on the vetting duties for you. By outsourcing your secret shopping, you can spend more time focusing on improvement strategies… and less time on hiring. 

‍

Preparing for the Evaluation

Now that you’ve hired a qualified secret shopper, what happens next? If you’ve contracted an agency, then the process is especially simple. Provide any information as requested, and then wait for the results. It’s that easy! 

On the other hand, if you’ve hired someone yourself, here’s what you’ll need to do: 

• Give clear objectives and expectations. For example, you may instruct your evaluator to enter a certain store, purchase a popular item, and then go back the next day to return the item. Tell them what kind of customer experience you want them to evaluate. 
• Provide instructions for feedback. If the secret shopper you hired is a good evaluator, they should have experience providing a thorough report. However, you can provide additional information about your specific business model if it will help. 
• Coordinate logistics. Your evaluation should happen on a fairly typical business day. However, in order to simulate an authentic experience, you won’t want your team to know the exact day and time the evaluation will happen—or who will be evaluating them. 
• Be prepared for criticism. Evaluations can make business owners uncomfortable. However, this is the best way to generate improvement strategies. Don’t make excuses for your team. Make adjustments! 
• Plan another CX evaluation in the near future. After you’ve had time to implement any changes to your CX, schedule another shop with your evaluator. That way, you can compare data and see if there’s been any improvement. 

Ultimately, you’ll want to do your best to run your business as you would every day. So don’t overthink things before the evaluation happens. There will be plenty of time for analysis after you’ve received your feedback. 

‍

A CX Evaluation Is the Best Way to Boost Business

Hiring a secret shopper for your small business is a strategic move that can significantly enhance your CX and drive long-term success. Secret shopping provides an objective, detailed look at your business operations from the customer's perspective that will highlight both strengths and areas needing improvement. By investing in regular CX evaluations, you can ensure continuous improvement, adapt to evolving customer expectations, and maintain a competitive edge in the market. 

Whether you operate a retail store, a fast food chain, or a digital services agency, the insights gained from a secret shopper can be transformative. Start incorporating secret shopping into your CX strategy today to unlock your business's full potential. Undoubtedly, this will ensure a consistent, exceptional customer experience.

‍